When Saving Becomes Too Good: Why Some Millionaires Struggle to Spend
There is an interesting paradox that can happen when someone
becomes very successful at building wealth:
The habits that helped them become wealthy can eventually
make it difficult for them to enjoy their wealth.
I was recently listening to Dave Ramsey, and one of his
callers brought this issue to life.
The caller was technically a millionaire. His home was paid
off and worth approximately $900,000, and he had around $200,000 in his 401(k).
On paper, his net worth was slightly above $1 million.
Yet he didn't feel like a millionaire.
At first, that may sound strange. After all, a
million-dollar net worth is a significant financial accomplishment.
But I think there is something very understandable about how
he felt.
A Millionaire on Paper Isn't Necessarily a Millionaire in
Liquidity
There is an important distinction between net worth and
financial liquidity.
If someone has a $900,000 paid-off home, that $900,000
absolutely counts toward their net worth. But they still need somewhere to
live.
They aren't walking around with $900,000 available to spend.
The same is true, to a different degree, with retirement
accounts. A 401(k) has real value and is an important component of someone's
financial wealth, but it is primarily designed for retirement. Accessing the
money before the appropriate time can involve taxes, penalties, restrictions,
and other considerations.
So imagine someone has:
- A
$900,000 paid-off house
- $200,000
in a 401(k)
- Very
little cash outside those assets
- No
consumer debt
Their net worth may exceed $1 million.
But their experience may be very different from someone who
has $1 million in liquid investments and cash.
Both people may technically be millionaires.
But they don't necessarily feel like millionaires.
And that's an important distinction.
The Psychology of Wealth Building
There is another issue that I think is even more
fascinating.
Building wealth requires discipline.
For decades, many financially successful people have trained
themselves to:
- Live
below their means
- Avoid
unnecessary debt
- Pay
off their mortgage
- Save
consistently
- Invest
for retirement
- Delay
gratification
- Avoid
lifestyle inflation
- Think
carefully before making large purchases
Those are excellent habits.
But after doing them for 20, 30, or 40 years, something
happens.
The behavior becomes part of your identity.
You don't simply practice frugality anymore.
You become a frugal person.
You don't simply save money.
You become someone who saves money.
You don't simply avoid unnecessary spending.
You begin to feel that avoiding spending is part of what
makes you financially responsible.
And this creates an interesting problem when you finally
reach a point where you actually have enough.
The Question Eventually Changes
Early in your financial journey, the question is:
How do I accumulate enough money?
But eventually, the question needs to become:
What is the money for?
Those are two completely different questions.
Someone who has spent decades mastering accumulation may never
have spent much time thinking about intentional consumption.
They know how to save.
They know how to invest.
They know how to pay off debt.
They know how to build a retirement account.
But when someone tells them, "You can afford to spend
some of this money," they may feel uncomfortable.
Their instinct is still:
Save more.
When Your Financial Scoreboard Becomes Your Identity
Saving has a very interesting psychological reward system.
You save $1,000, and your account goes up.
You pay off $10,000 of debt, and your debt balance goes
down.
You contribute another $20,000 to your retirement account,
and your net worth increases.
There is a scoreboard.
And people who are highly disciplined often become attached
to watching that scoreboard move in the right direction.
Spending is different.
You might spend $10,000 on an incredible family vacation.
You may create memories that last for decades.
You may experience something you've dreamed about for years.
But when you look at your bank account afterward, the number
is smaller.
Financially, the scoreboard went backward.
Emotionally, however, you may have gained something
enormously valuable.
That's where the transition becomes difficult.
Accumulation has a measurable financial result.
Consumption often has an experiential result.
People who have spent their lives measuring progress through
their financial statements may have difficulty recognizing the value of the
second kind of return.
The Purpose of Wealth
This is why I believe financial planning needs to be about more
than simply accumulating as much money as possible.
Money is a tool.
It can provide security.
It can buy freedom.
It can reduce stress.
It can give you options.
It can allow you to spend more time with the people you
love.
It can allow you to travel.
It can allow you to help your children or grandchildren.
It can allow you to give generously.
It can allow you to work because you want to rather
than because you have to.
But none of those things happen simply because your net
worth appears on a spreadsheet.
At some point, money has to be connected to purpose.
That's the part of financial planning that I think sometimes
gets overlooked.
I'm Still a Big Believer in Eliminating Debt
None of this means that I disagree with the importance of
getting out of debt.
Quite the opposite.
Debt can consume future income and limit your freedom.
Eliminating unnecessary debt can dramatically improve your financial position
and create the foundation for wealth.
Living below your means is also an incredibly powerful
habit.
Saving and investing consistently matter.
We spend enormous amounts of time teaching people how to
make money, save money, invest money, and protect money, but we don't always
teach people how to use money intentionally.
The important thing is that money becomes a tool rather
than the objective.
That's a profound distinction.
And I wouldn't completely dismiss the "don't spend
it" instinct
Some people genuinely don't need to increase their spending.
A person who enjoys a modest lifestyle, has a paid-off house,
plenty of retirement assets, and doesn't particularly care about expensive
cars, luxury travel, or a larger house isn't necessarily making a mistake
because they don't spend aggressively.
The issue isn't low spending.
The issue is when someone wants to spend on meaningful
things but psychologically cannot give themselves permission to do so.
That's a very different problem.
The goal shouldn't be to eliminate spending.
The goal should be to eliminate mindless spending.
There is a huge difference.
Spending $8,000 on something you don't care about because
you want to impress other people is very different from spending $8,000 on an
experience you've dreamed about for years.
Buying a bigger house simply because you can afford it is
different from using your money to help your family.
Buying things that clutter your life is different from
buying back your time.
The question isn't simply:
"Can I afford it?"
It should also be:
"Does this spending serve the life I am trying to
build?"
And ironically, the person may have succeeded at
accumulating wealth so well that their greatest financial challenge becomes learning
how to use it.
The ultimate financial transition
I'd describe the journey this way:
Stage 1: Survival
"I need enough money to be okay."
Stage 2: Stability
"I need an emergency fund and manageable
expenses."
Stage 3: Debt elimination
"I need to stop sending my income to creditors."
Stage 4: Accumulation
"I need to build assets."
Stage 5: Financial independence
"My assets and income can support my life without
depending entirely on my labor."
Stage 6: Stewardship
"How should I use this wealth to create the life I
actually value?"
That last transition is easy to overlook.
Financial planning shouldn't only teach people how to
accumulate money. It should teach them how to eventually convert money into the
things that made accumulating it worthwhile.
You can be extremely disciplined about money without
becoming psychologically imprisoned by the discipline.
And perhaps the ultimate sign that a wealth-building system
worked isn't simply that someone reaches $1 million, $2 million, or $5 million.
It's that when they finally have enough, they know what
"enough" is—and they know how to use the surplus intentionally.
Comments
Post a Comment