You Posted It, But Can You Deduct It? The Sami Case and the Tax Rules Influencers Need to Know

 

The recent Sami v. Commissioner Tax Court decision should be a wake-up call for influencers, content creators, and small-business owners who think that simply putting something on a business credit card—or posting about it online—automatically makes it a business expense.

A lot of social-media influencer tax advice is for show. The Sami case is a good example of what can happen when you try to stretch business deductions beyond what the facts and documentation can support.

Tax laws are not written to be interpreted according to whatever treatment best fits your personal situation. There is context behind every transaction, and that context includes the operation of the business as a whole.

The Tax Court found that Sami could not deduct a number of expenses he characterized as marketing, including expensive celebrity experiences and event-related expenditures. The court focused not merely on whether these activities generated content or increased engagement, but on whether the expenses were primarily undertaken for business rather than personal purposes.

Sami spent substantial amounts on experiences involving celebrities and high-profile events. Among the expenses were approximately $10,000 for two Grammy tickets, $2,700 for two Emmy tickets, $8,912 for an experience with Benedict Cumberbatch, $4,151 for Matt Damon, and $2,600 for Mark Ruffalo. He also paid for a personalized video from Chris Evans, attended Tiger Jam, and paid for opportunities involving athletes such as Tom Brady, Drew Brees and John McEnroe.

His argument was essentially that these experiences created content, increased attention to his social-media accounts, increased followers and views, and could ultimately help generate advertising revenue.

And this is where people need to understand the distinction.

The fact that an expenditure produces some business benefit does not automatically make the expenditure a deductible business expense.

The Tax Court looked at the underlying purpose of the spending. The court was not persuaded that Sami primarily incurred these expenses as business marketing expenditures. Among other things, the court considered the nature of the experiences themselves and the fact that they were highly desirable, expensive experiences that also provided personal enjoyment, status, and the opportunity to interact with famous people.

Think about how important that distinction is.

Suppose I spend $10,000 to attend the Grammys.

I take pictures.

I post them on Instagram.

My followers increase.

My engagement increases.

People comment.

Maybe I even gain new followers who eventually see my sponsored content.

Those things may all be true.

But the tax question isn't simply:

"Did this generate content?"

The more fundamental question is:

"Why did you spend the $10,000 in the first place?"

If the underlying transaction is essentially a luxury or personal experience that you later turned into content, calling it "marketing" after the fact does not necessarily change its character.

That is an extremely important lesson for influencers.

There is a temptation to think:

"I make content for a living, therefore anything that appears in my content is a business expense."

That is far too broad.

If that were the rule, almost any personal lifestyle expense could potentially be repackaged as marketing.

A luxury vacation becomes "travel content."

A designer handbag becomes "fashion content."

A five-star dinner becomes "food content."

A concert becomes "entertainment content."

A celebrity meet-and-greet becomes "networking."

A luxury car becomes "automotive content."

The existence of content is not the end of the analysis.

The underlying facts matter.

And Sami is a particularly useful example because the court didn't say that influencers can never deduct expensive or unusual expenses. The decision turned on the particular facts and, importantly, the court's conclusion that these expenditures were primarily personal rather than primarily undertaken for business.

There is another important point here.

Sami argued that the celebrity interactions helped his social-media presence. But during the tax years at issue, he did not receive income from his social-media influencing activity. The court also found that he hadn't established that these celebrity-related expenditures materially benefited his other businesses, such as transportation or ticket sales. 

So you can't simply connect the dots years later and say:

"I spent money → I got content → the content got views → views can produce revenue → therefore the original expenditure was a business expense."

Tax law requires you to establish the business connection based on the facts and applicable rules—not simply construct a chain of hypothetical future benefits.

And this is where I think influencers need to be especially careful with the idea of "luxury = content = deduction."

The more inherently personal an expenditure is, the more important the facts and documentation become.

If you are going to claim that a $10,000 experience was a legitimate business expenditure, you should be able to explain contemporaneously:

  • What business objective were you pursuing?
  • Why was this particular expenditure reasonably necessary to achieve that objective?
  • What was the expected business benefit?
  • What evidence supports that business purpose?
  • Was the expenditure primarily business or personal?
  • Who was the intended business audience?
  • What business activity actually resulted?
  • What records did you maintain at the time?

And importantly, don't create that explanation only after the IRS questions the deduction.

That is one of the bigger lessons that should be taken from Sami case.

The problem isn't that influencers have unusual businesses.

The problem is assuming that because your business involves your lifestyle, your lifestyle automatically becomes a business expense.

It doesn't.

A legitimate influencer business can absolutely have legitimate marketing expenses. But the tax analysis still starts with the actual transaction, its purpose, its business connection, and the evidence supporting it.

You can't just take a personal luxury experience, put a camera in front of it, and assume the tax law has now transformed it into a deductible marketing expense.

That distinction is extremely important.

One of the worst practices I see is treating a bank or credit-card statement as if it were sufficient documentation by itself.

A statement might show:

STAPLES — $25.00

Great. You have established that you spent $25 at Staples.

But what did you buy?

Was it printer paper for the business?
Ink?
Office supplies?
Or was it bottled or sparkling water for personal consumption?

The merchant name does not answer that question.

I recently saw an influencer purchase sparkling water at Staples and treat it as a business expense because the credit-card statement showed Staples—and Staples is generally associated with office supplies.

That is not how substantiation works.

The fact that you purchased something from a business that sells office supplies does not establish that what you purchased was an office supply, nor does it establish a business purpose.

This is where many people get into trouble during an audit. Their records may prove that money left their bank account, but they don't establish what was purchased, why it was purchased, how it was used, and how it benefited the business.

And that was one of the significant problems in Sami.

For many expenses, the evidence amounted largely to credit-card or bank statements without receipts or other documentation showing exactly what was purchased and establishing the business connection. The court also sustained accuracy-related penalties. 

What makes the case particularly interesting is that Sami had both a bachelor's and master's degree in accounting and had previously worked in PwC's risk-assurance group. The court considered his accounting background when rejecting his reasonable-cause defense to the penalties.

That part really caught my attention. And at its very least, Accounting teaching the importance of good record keeping, which he barely had any of.

Because this isn't some obscure, sophisticated tax concept.

At its core, the lesson is basic:

A business expense needs a legitimate business purpose, and you need records that can demonstrate that purpose.

You cannot simply work backward from a purchase and ask, "How can I characterize this as a business expense?"

The proper question is:

"Why did the business incur this expense, and what evidence do I have to demonstrate that?"

And posting something on Instagram, TikTok, or YouTube doesn't automatically answer that question either.

The Sami case does not mean influencers cannot deduct legitimate business expenses. The Tax Court did allow certain deductions and applied the same general tax principles that apply to other businesses. What it rejected was the idea that personal expenditures become deductible simply because they produce content or some business benefit.

That's the part I hope people take away from this case.

Don't build your tax position around what you want an expense to be.

Build it around what the transaction actually was, why the business needed it, and whether your records can tell that story years later when the IRS—or eventually the Tax Court—asks questions.

Because once you're sitting in Tax Court, a credit-card statement saying "Staples" isn't going to magically explain what was in the bag.

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Step-Up in Basis and Trusts: Common Misconceptions

Tax Write-Offs & Vehicles: A Common Misunderstanding

Real Estate Rentals is a Business, not A Tax "Loophole"